主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 1002-8587  CN 11-2765/K
国家社科基金资助期刊

journal6 ›› 2017, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 84-98.

• 学术专论 • 上一篇    下一篇

“崇德改制” 与“丙子之役”:朝中交往中的正统性问题

  

  1. 中国政法大学法律古籍整理研究所
  • 出版日期:2017-05-15 发布日期:2017-05-15
  • 作者简介:桂涛( 1980 - ) ,男,中国政法大学法律古籍整理研究所讲师,北京100088; guitao0121@163. com

The“Chongde Reformation”and“the Second Manchu Invasion of Korea”: The Legitimacy Problem in Association Between Qing Dynasty and Joseon Korea

  1. Institue for Chinese Ancient Legal Documents,China University of Political Science and Law
  • Online:2017-05-15 Published:2017-05-15
  • About author:GUI Tao ( Institue for Chinese Ancient Legal Documents,China University of Political Science and Law; guitao0121@163. com)

摘要: 在观念层面上,“崇德改制”与随后发生的“丙子之役” 这两个事件之间具有特殊的意义及关联性。在朝鲜看来,“崇德改制”关涉整个天下秩序的变更,表达了金- 清政权取代大明、成为新的天下共主的诉求。对于金- 清政权而言, 其诉求的正当性根据在于天下“惟有德者居之”,而现实基础则是蒙古与朝鲜的臣服。相较蒙古,“小中华” 朝鲜的归顺尤具特殊意义,它既能增强皇太极有德之君的形象,又能消解明朝支配天下的正当性基础。因此,征朝就成为清政权改号称帝后的当务之急。通过“丙子之役”,清朝的军事征服将朝鲜纳入其政治框架,但并没有完全取得预期效果,朝鲜仍然不承认清朝的正统性。

Abstract: Conceptually, there was a special significance to the connection between the “Chongde Reformation”in 1636 and the subsequent battle between the Qing Dynasty and Joseon Korea,known as “the second Manchu invasion of Korea. ”From the view point of Joseon Korea, the “Chongde Reformation”reflected the Qing’s desire to replace the Ming Dynasty and involved the transformation of the world order. The legitimacy of the Qing’s claim was based on the idea that only a ruler with the highest moral standing had the qualification to be the world’s ruler. To prove this claim it was necessary to conquer Mongolia and Joseon Korea. In contrast with Mongolia,Joseon Korea’s submission to the Qing had special significance,which reinforced Hong Taiji’s moral image and deconstructed the legitimacy of Ming as the world ruler. Therefore,after the“Chongde Reformation”,the primary task of the Qing became putting Joseon Korea in subjugation. Through the second Manchu invasion of Korea,Joseon Korea was incorporated into the political framework of the Qing Dynasty,but still did not admit the Qing’s legitimacy,which suggested that the Qing’s conquest did not completely achieve the expected result.