主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 1002-8587  CN 11-2765/K
国家社科基金资助期刊

journal6 ›› 2011, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (3): 88-98.

• 学术专论 • 上一篇    下一篇

义和团运动中李秉衡的言行考察

  

  1. 美国哈佛大学费正清研究中心
  • 出版日期:2011-08-15 发布日期:2011-08-15
  • 作者简介:孔祥吉(1943—),男,美国哈佛大学费正清研究中心研究员

Li Bingheng's Words and Deeds During the Boxer Rebellion

  • Online:2011-08-15 Published:2011-08-15

摘要:  本文以档案为依据,叙述、考证了李秉衡在义和团运动中的表现。慈禧决定对列强宣战后,急切召李秉衡进京,京师的守旧势力嚣张一时,而希望李氏进京的均为顽固派官僚。李秉衡率部北上途中,攻毁教堂,入京后,迟迟未赴前线,先后五次被慈禧召见,并与义和团一起围攻使馆。本文引用清档,论证李秉衡陷害主和派,导致慈禧、徐桐、刚毅等顽固派,将许景澄、袁昶等杀害的重要事实。本文认为,李秉衡在义和团运动中的行为,与守旧派的愚昧排外政策,有着千丝万缕的联系,如肯定李秉衡在义和团运动中举动是爱国的,则又要面对如何评价支持、重用李秉衡的慈禧、徐桐、刚毅等人的难题。

Abstract: On the basis of archival records,this article describes and explores Li Bingheng's performance during the Boxer Rebellion. After declaring war against the Western powers,Empress Dowager Cixi urgently called Li to the capital. At the time conservative groups prevailed in Beijing,and all who hoped Li would come to the capital were obstinate bureaucrats. During his march north Li attacked and destroyed churches,but upon reaching Beijing he hesitated to go
to the front. Cixi received him in audience five times,and he assaulted the diplomatic quarters along with the Boxers.This paper demonstrates that Li framed the peace faction,with the result that Cixi,Xu Tong,and Gangyi killed Xu Jingcheng and Yuan Chang. The author believes that Li Bingheng's behavior during the Boxer Rebellion was closely connected to the foolish xenophobia of the conservative faction. If Li's deeds are regarded as patriotic,then we must confront the difficult question of how to evaluate those who supported him.