主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 1002-8587  CN 11-2765/K
国家社科基金资助期刊

journal6 ›› 2012, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 99-111.

• 学术专论 • 上一篇    下一篇

《满洲实录》成书考

  

  1. 华东师范大学古籍所
  • 出版日期:2012-05-15 发布日期:2012-05-15
  • 作者简介:杨勇军( 1972—),男,华东师范大学古籍所博士生; 上海 200241

Research on the Book of Manzhou Shilu

  • Online:2012-05-15 Published:2012-05-15

摘要: 《满洲实录》是记载满族先世源流及清太祖努尔哈赤事迹的官书。本文考证了《满洲实录》的前身《太祖实录战图》的来历以及与太祖实录的关系,澄清了《太祖实录战图》是一本没有文字的图册。还考证了《满洲实录》成书的时间,并从文献记载和历史事实两方面,指出《满洲实录》83幅插图当中,前6图是乾隆时期所补绘。另外,本文还论证了《满洲实录》中清高宗题诗注文所言"实录八册"为《太祖实录战图》八册,而非后世学者以为的《满洲实录》八卷。在以上考据的基础上,本文首次在史学界揭发《满洲实录》是一部清高宗亲自参与作伪的伪书,并分析了清朝统治者作伪的动机。最后,鉴于《满洲实录》是一部伪书,本文还重新评定了《满洲实录》史料价值。

Abstract: The Manzhou Shilu ( Chronological Records of Manchu) is an official book that records the origin of the Manchu ancestors and Nurhaci's deeds.This article discusses the origin of the precursor of the Manzhou Shilu———the Taizu Shilu Zhantu and its relationship with the Taizu Shilu.It clarifies that the Taizu Shilu Zhantu is not Manzhou Shilu and demonstrates that the first six of the eighty-three pictures were drawn during the Qianlong reign. Furthermore, the eight volumes of the Shilu mentioned in a poem composed by Emperor Qianlong actually referred to the Taizu Shilu Zhantu, not to Manzhou Shilu as the previous scholars argued.Given the above evidence,this article argues that the Manzhou Shilu is a forged book and that Emperor Qianlong himself took a role in the forgery process. This article also discusses the motivation of the forgery and the historical value of the Manchou Shilu.